Photo: Scott Legato/Getty Images

feature
Foo Fighters Are An Indestructible Music Juggernaut. But Taylor Hawkins' Death Shows That They're Human Beings, Too.
In the recent Foo Fighters deluge — a memoir, a horror flick, memeable stunts, a GRAMMY-nominated album — it became easy to take them for granted. But drummer Taylor Hawkins' untimely death reminds us that they're people, not cartoon characters.
Editor's Note: Foo Fighters will no longer perform at the 2022 GRAMMYs, although a tribute to Taylor Hawkins will take place.
It is no slight to Foo Fighters to say they saturated music fans over the past year.
Primarily, they put out their GRAMMY-nominated album, Medicine at Midnight, and Dave Grohl's bestselling memoir, The Storyteller. But then there was everything around those press cycles, which could prove overwhelming to any music lover — the horror movie, Studio 666; the children they invited to shred onstage; the reignited beef with the Westboro Baptist Church. When you factor in the world tour, the Rock Hall induction, the talk-show appearances, and the golden throne, it's hard to imagine even the most hardcore fan needing more Foo Fighters in 2022.
But in a Rolling Stone cover story from last year, Grohl underlined how all this prolificity wasn't just for its own sake — it came from broken hearts and a need to pick up the pieces. "We were people coming from bands that ended prematurely, that were not finished making music," he said, nodding to the deaths of Kurt Cobain of Nirvana, Grohl's former band, and Darby Crash of the Germs, the pioneering punk band co-founded by Foos guitarist Pat Smear. "So we imagined this to be some sort of continuation, and that our band was about life. So why not celebrate it every way that we can?"
So the Foos raged against the dying of the light for a quarter century as ambassadors of rock innocence and goodwill. And then a stunning loss — of Taylor Hawkins, the smiley, good-natured drum godhead in the back — gobsmacked the music community.
Hours before the 12-time GRAMMY winners were set to take the stage at Festival Estéreo Picnic in Bogotá, Colombia — and a little more than a week before they were to perform at the 2022 GRAMMY Awards — the band tweeted an announcement that left rock fans reeling. "The Foo Fighters family is devastated by the tragic and untimely loss of our beloved Taylor Hawkins," it read. "His musical spirit and infectious laughter will live on with all of us forever." The drummer was 50.
While no cause or location was immediately given, the Bogotá municipal government revealed he passed away in his hotel room. And according to the Metropolitan Police of Bogotá, "The cause of death has yet to be established," but "According to those close to him, the death could be related to the consumption of drugs."
Recording Academy CEO Harvey Mason jr. shared his condolences to Hawkins' family and fans in a statement. (At the 2022 GRAMMY Awards, Foo Fighters are nominated for Best Rock Performance for "Making a Fire," Best Rock Song for "Waiting on a War" and Best Rock Album for Medicine at Midnight.)
With Hawkins' death, the Foo Fighters' unstoppable train ground to a halt. Just days ago, one could reliably pick up their phone and see Hawkins' goofy grin, his surfer-boy looks, his acrobatics behind the kit. Being a Foo Fighters fan meant always guessing — what would they get up to this week? Rip into a Bee Gees cover, turning Madison Square Garden into a massive dance party? Release an album of speed-metal songs under an alias? Now, no matter what Foo Fighters do next, they'll never be the same.
Hawkins was born in Fort Worth, Texas, in 1972, and raised in Laguna Beach, California. In the early 1990s, he worked with Canadian singer Sass Jordan, before rising to the global stage as Alanis Morrissette's touring drummer during her Jagged Little Pill era. After Foo Fighters' then-drummer William Goldsmith left the band during the sessions for 1997's The Colour and the Shape, Grohl offered the drum throne to Hawkins.
In his memoir, The Storyteller, Grohl expressed how dearly he loved Hawkins. "Part Beavis and Butthead, part Dumb and Dumber, we were a hyperactive blur of Parliament Lights and air drumming wherever we went," he wrote, saying they had become "practically inseparable."
On classic Foos records, from 1999's There is Nothing Left to Lose to 2011's Wasting Light and right up to Medicine at Midnight, Hawkins pulled off a nearly impossible balance — not copying or upstaging the other famous drummer in the band, but remaining totally distinctive and recognizable. At first, though, Hawkins felt like he couldn't possibly measure up to Grohl, who is widely considered one of the greatest drummers of all time.
"And at one point, I just said to Dave, 'Listen, dude, I just don't think I can do this,'" Hawkins recalled to Rolling Stone. "And what he said chokes me up a little. He's like, 'You're gonna play some drums on this.' I did half the drums on it, because he f<em></em>*in' held my hand through it, like an older brother, best friend does. That's why we're here today."
Few drummers can make a song pump and slam like Grohl. But Hawkins — influenced commensurately by Queen's Roger Taylor and the Police's Stewart Copeland — had a bouncy, dynamic style all his own. And with Grohl's support, he became not only a worthy member of Foo Fighters, but the heart of its propulsion system.
Despite Grohl initially singing all the vocals and playing all the instruments on Foo Fighters records, his accompanists have never been anonymous action figures on stage. Hawkins, guitarists Pat Smear and Chris Shiflett, bassist Nate Mendel, and keyboardist Rami Jaffee — all of them bound by a manic sense of brotherhood — are just as crucial to the band's sound and appeal. Both live and in the studio, the Foos brought heavy artillery — an album could be an HBO special, a concert an overwhelming spectacle that leaves you laughing, dancing and crying.
That reliability and ubiquity can be a double-edged sword. It engenders the notion that the Foos will always be here: You can potentially check out for a few years and come back — they'll be waiting for you. But as we learned with beloved artists (and human cartoon characters) Prince and Tom Petty, the musician who's seemingly always on screen can be gone in an instant. Touring around the world with a permanent smile doesn't mean one doesn't have their own inner demons and can't be yanked off the planet — from all of us.
It's unknown what the future of Foo Fighters may entail. For now, the band has sent their love to Hawkins' wife, children and family, adding: "We ask that their privacy be treated with the utmost respect in this unimaginably difficult time."
There are reams of songs, albums, skits, and YouTube videos by which to remember Hawkins, but by all rights, we should have decades more of them. This cruel fact casts the recent ubiquity of Foo Fighters in a different light. This yearslong music and media cycle — which would work almost any other band to the point of exhaustion — wasn't just for attention; it was to have as much fun and make as much music as humanly possible. Because as Grohl and company know from experience, tomorrow isn't guaranteed.
"I don't want to f<em></em><em>ing die! I know it's inevitable, but I don't want to," Grohl told Rolling Stone*. "That's gonna be such a drag. I'll fight it as long as I can." In the same interview, Smear characterized Foo Fighters as "life-lovers" — contrasting their philosophy with Cobain's "I hate myself and I want to die" theatrics. For Foo Fighters, life sprung out of grief and pain. And that's audible at the very heartbeat of the band — the one Hawkins provided.
"I think Taylor really underestimates his importance in this band," Grohl added. "Maybe because he's not the original drummer, but, my God, what would we be without Taylor Hawkins? Could you imagine? It would be a completely different thing … Taylor's insecurity pushes him to overachieve."
For the jubilant, outrageous, tortured Hawkins, rock was the juice of life. Tragically, we'll never see Hawkins' bared teeth and shock of blonde hair behind Foo Fighters again. But his life, legacy and passing prove once and for all: Strip away the memes and the noise, and you've got human beings just trying to work through agony and find their way to joy.
Remembering The Rolling Stones' Charlie Watts: 5 Essential Performances By The Drum Legend

Photo: Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic, Inc
list
11 Reasons Why 1993 Was Nirvana's Big Year
While 1991 was the year Nirvana broke, the Seattle grunge pioneers continued their impressive streak. With the release of 'In Utero,' multiple massive shows and now-legendary appearances on MTV programs, 1993 ended up being Nirvana’s most productive year.
By most measures, 1992 was a massive year for Nirvana. The Seattle grunge pioneers achieved international fame when their major label debut, Nevermind, topped the charts and was nominated for Best Alternative Music Album at the 34th GRAMMY Awards.
But the band (and lead singer/guitarist Kurt Cobain in particular) quickly became overwhelmed by their unexpected success. Nirvana retreated for most of the year, only playing about a month’s worth of shows and delaying work on a follow up album.
So there was much ground to make up in 1993.
But Kurt Cobain, Krist Novoselic, and Dave Grohl rose to the challenge. There were a few bumps along the way — such as a kerfuffle when it was reported that Nirvana bowed to record company pressure to remix tracks on their new album, thus making them "sellouts" (the band insisted they alone decided what changes needed to be made) — but '93 ended up being one of Nirvana’s most productive years.
Thirty years ago, Nirvana released an acclaimed third album (In Utero), an indie single ("Oh, The Guilt"), and created one of their most haunting videos ("Heart-Shaped Box"). And throughout their first U.S. tour since 1991, the band proved again and again what a powerful live act they were — whether playing a former movie house or a mega stadium — showing that a noisy band could still pack a punch by going acoustic.
In honor of the 30th anniversary of In Utero (and a forthcoming reissue), GRAMMY.com revisits 11 of Nirvana’s most memorable moments from 1993.
Nirvana Affirm Their Indie Cred With "Oh, The Guilt"
Nirvana recorded three songs during their sole studio session in 1992. "Curmudgeon" ended up as the B-side of "Lithium," "Return of the Rat" appeared on a Greg Sage compilation, and "Oh, The Guilt" finally turned up as part of a split single with Jesus Lizard on Touch and Go Records.
Back in 1988, Cobain had sent several copies of Nirvana’s first demo to the Chicago-based Touch and Go. Following the major label success of Nevermind, Nirvana clearly wanted to make the effort to keep in touch with their indie roots.
"Nirvana became like the Beatles of the ’90s, but they still wanted to do it," Jesus Lizard’s David Yow told Seattle music magazine The Rocket. "And we had to figure out, well, do we want to do this and look like we’re riding on Nirvana’s coattails, or we could just do it and not worry about it, which is what we ended up doing."
Released on Feb. 22, the grinding "Oh, The Guilt" set the stage for the rawer sound of Nirvana’s next album.
The Band Played "One Of The Best Shows Of Their Lives" At The Cow Palace
Nirvana had played only five major U.S. concerts in 1992, so there was much anticipation for this concert in Daly City, just south of San Francisco. Nirvana bassist Krist Novoselic organized the show, a benefit for the Tresnjevka Womens’ Group, a Zagreb-based organization aiding Bosnian War rape survivors and refugees.
"The Cow Palace show was high-stakes," says Michael Azerrad, author of Come As You Are: The Story of Nirvana (due to be reissued next month in an expanded edition), who was at the show. "Some of the people who worked with Nirvana were a little dubious about the material the band had recently recorded for In Utero. Kurt, Krist and Dave knew they had something to prove. But they hadn’t played live in a couple of months — and now they had to get up in front of an audience and play one of the best shows of their lives. And they did just that."
At the April 9 show, the band came roaring out of the gate with "Rape Me," and went on to deliver a fiery 23-song set, debuting a number of songs from In Utero, and encoring with a noise jam that ended with the obligatory instrument destruction. In Azerrad’s view, "The Cow Palace show was truly a triumph."
Fans Got A Taste Of Pre-Fame Nirvana In 1991: The Year Punk Broke
When David Markey packed up his Super-8 camera to follow various indie bands on a European tour in 1991, he had no idea he’d be capturing Nirvana on the verge of becoming the biggest band in the world. In Come As You Are: The Story of Nirvana Cobain recalled this as the period when "there’s so much excitement in the air you can just taste it," and it’s riveting to see the band without the baggage of worldwide fame dragging them down.
Markey's documentary, 1991: The Year Punk Broke, was released on home video in April 1993. "Smells Like Teen Spirit," not yet released as a single, sounds fresh and invigorating; older numbers like "School" and "Negative Creep" are sizzling.
"That tour was easily the most fun I've ever had on any tour, anywhere, anytime," says Markey. "And that feeling was shared by everyone who was on it, I promise. Forget the fact that Nirvana and Sonic Youth were on fire at every stop along the way. Same with the other bands: Dinosaur Jr. Babes In Toyland. Gumball. And of course the Ramones.
"I remember nothing but smiles and laughter," he continues. "The fact that I was tasked with documenting it with nine hours of Super-8 film cartridges shoved into a giant suitcase seemed like an afterthought. It wasn’t just a job. It was everything."
The "Sliver" Video Offers A Glimpse Into Cobain's World
In December 1992, DGC, the same label that put out Nevermind, released Incesticide, a collection of Nirvana’s non-album tracks. The video for "Sliver" was belatedly released to promote it in May 1993, but what’s more interesting is the glimpse it gives into Cobain’s private world.
Originally released as a single on Sub Pop Records, the song is a childhood reminiscence that showed Nirvana charting a new course into more pop-driven territory. The band members look like giddy teenagers practicing in their parent’s garage, and the location is, indeed, Cobain’s own garage. It’s a room filled with ephemera: a wind-up toy of a monkey playing the cymbals, a can of Prairie Belt sausages, a copy of Better Homes and Gardens with the words "Indie punx still sucks" scrawled on the mailing label. It’s no surprise to see a poster of Mudhoney on the wall — but Mikhail Gorbachev as well? As a bonus, Cobain’s daughter Frances Bean Cobain pops up repeatedly throughout the proceedings.
Nirvana Go Bigger, And Acoustic, At The Roseland Ballroom
Nirvana was a last-minute addition to the roster of acts performing during the New Music Seminar, a summer convention for music industry professionals in New York City. The July 23 performance served as a dry run for Nirvana’s Unplugged performance later in the year.
The band also experimented with filling out their sound by adding a second guitarist (John Duncan as a temporary fill in). They performed most of the songs from In Utero, sounding a good deal tougher live than on record. Then, to the audience’s surprise, the band sat down and brought on cellist Lori Goldston for a short acoustic set. The set is initially hampered by a poor sound mix (Novoselic can be heard calling out "More cello!") and disinterest on the part of some loudly talking audience members.
Listening now, it’s an impressive moment, as the band works to make their performance more than simply a standard run through of the hits. As Everett True wrote in his review of the show for Melody Maker, "Cobain is, in his way, a master manipulator, a brilliant strategist who understands that noise alone is not drama and that good hooks always draw blood."
Nirvana Raised Money For The Mia Zapata Investigative Fund
Theater in Seattle raised money to help solve the murder of Gits’ singer Mia Zapata, who had been killed the previous month, with TAD headlining. Nirvana was added to the bill to boost sales.
While the crowds turned up, according to guitar tech Earnie Bailey, they nearly missed out. The show was running overtime, meaning a full changeover of gear between TAD’s and Nirvana’s sets would mean Nirvana could only play one or two songs. Instead, the TAD crew allowed Nirvana to use their gear, and Nirvana went on to have great fun with their set, throwing in covers of Led Zeppelin’s "No Quarter," and, more unexpectedly Terry Jacks’ weeper "Seasons in the Sun."
The show has never been released in any form, so there was great excitement when a 20-minute excerpt appeared on YouTube this past August. It was Nirvana’s last show as a trio.
Cobain & Co. Release Their Third Album, In Utero
Nirvana’s long-awaited third album was first released in the U.S. on vinyl on Sept. 14; the CD version, the dominant audio format at the time, followed on Sept. 21, and debuted on Billboard’s Top Albums chart at No. 1.
In Utero stands as Cobain’s most personal work, his response to the turbulent events of 1992: the sudden rush of fame, substance abuse, parenthood, and the demonization of his wife. In contrast to the commercial sheen of Nevermind, In Utero has a harsh, confrontational sound; songs like "Scentless Apprentice," and "tourette’s" are frightening in their intensity. And even if you don’t take lines like "What is wrong with me?" ("Radio Friendly Unit Shifter") and "Look on the bright side is suicide" ("Milk It") as foreshadowing, they’re nonetheless indicative of the pervasive sense of unease that permeates the record.
From the opening salvo of "Serve the Servants" that caustically rejects fame ("Teenage angst has paid off well/Now I’m bored and old") to the plea for transcendence in the closing "All Apologies," In Utero is an album of emotional pain that rivals John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band. A 30th anniversary release of In Utero is set for October 2023.
"Heart-Shaped Box" Single And Video Are Released
Released in September, "Heart-Shaped Box" shares the same sonic dynamics as "Smells Like Teen Spirit" (quiet verse, loud chorus), but is tempered by an underlying melancholy, along with striking imagery ("meat-eating orchids," "umbilical noose"). The song’s video was equally compelling — and spooky. The main set is a creepy forest where fetuses dangle from the trees and an elderly man in a Santa Claus hat climbs on a cross to be crucified.
In the director’s cut of the video, the last verse shows Cobain lying asleep in a field as mist slowly rises around him, an image that became even more haunting to look at after his death (in the initial cut, Cobain is shown singing the final verse). The hospital sequences echo the album’s themes of illness and decay. Cobain later told MTV, "That video has come closer to what I’ve seen in my mind, what I’ve envisioned, than any other video."
Nirvana Appear On "Saturday Night Live"
This was the first opportunity for most fans to see how In Utero’s songs translated to live performance. First up is "Heart-Shaped Box," more powerful than on record, Cobain’s vocals transitioning easily between the subdued verses and the raging chorus.
"Rape Me" debuted on the 1991 tour; Cobain subsequently added a bridge attacking media hypocrisy, and this performance burns with righteous fury. The show also marked the debut of Pat Smear, formerly guitarist with L.A. punk act the Germs, to the lineup, sharing guitar duties with Cobain. He’s certainly the most animated band member, bouncing around the stage with high-spirited energy. And don’t overlook how forcefully Grohl attacks his drum kit.
Nirvana Do A Masterful Performance On MTV’s "Unplugged"
The idea of an incendiary band like Nirvana doing an "unplugged," sans their raging volume, seemed an oxymoron. Even the group seemed uncertain how to handle the task. The show’s producer, Alex Coletti, later recalled how MTV execs were unhappy that the band didn’t want to perform their signature hits, and that their choice of musical guest was not a similar headliner like Eddie Vedder, but a lesser-known indie act, the Meat Puppets. Before the taping on Nov. 18, the band hadn’t even done a complete run through of the set.
It was a situation ripe for disaster. Instead, Nirvana pulled off what’s considered one of their most masterful performances. The band chose their more acoustically-driven numbers ("About a Girl") and songs that worked in a stripped down format ("Come As You Are"), though they weren’t entirely unplugged; Cobain’s guitar was put through a Fender Twin Reverb amp and effects boxes.
The covers proved to be the most interesting choices — David Bowie’s "The Man Who Sold the World" was mesmerizing — and the Meat Puppets’ numbers underscored Nirvana’s own idiosyncratic indie roots. "I thought the Meat Puppets’ inclusion was especially magical," says Lori Goldston, cellist during Nirvana’s fall tour. "Curt [Kirkwood, Meat Puppets’ guitarist] was used to being the lead, not an accompanist, and afterwards he mentioned that it felt luxurious to play guitar without having to worry about doubling as a vocalist," a hint at how collaborations with other artists might have gone.
The band finished up with an extraordinary performance of Huddie "Leadbelly" Ledbetter’s "Where Did You Sleep Last Night?" that left the audience stunned.
Nirvana Close Out 1993 With MTV’s Live and Loud
Pearl Jam’s loss was Nirvana’s gain. After Eddie Vedder declined to appear at MTV’s New Year’s Eve gig (which was actually taped on December 13), Pearl Jam was cut from the lineup and Nirvana’s set was extended (other acts included Cypress Hill and the Breeders).
The band had been on the road for two months now, and were firing on all pistons; the relentless "Radio Friendly Unit Shifter" proved to be a powerhouse opening number and there was a scorching performance of "Scentless Apprentice." One moment not seen in the original broadcast (the entire show’s since been released on DVD) was when an audience member shrieked out "MTV sucks!" In response, Cobain smiled and quite sensibly asked, "Then why are you here?" But he perhaps revealed his own feelings about the network when, during the closing jam/end-of-show destruction, he looks straight into the camera and spits onto the lens.
The final destruction sequence was particularly intricate on this night, starting out simply enough with Novoselic strumming his bass, then rising and falling in volume over the course of ten minutes, climaxing with Cobain swinging his guitar and decapitating one of the stage props. It brought Nirvana’s year to a suitably explosive close.
How Hole Moved Beyond The Grunge Scene By Going Pop On 'Celebrity Skin'

Photo: Steve Jennings/WireImage
list
7 Unforgettable Sets From Outside Lands 2023: Foo Fighters' Special Guests, Lana Del Rey's Return & A Superhero DJ Shaq
The 15th edition of San Francisco’s foggy summer festival brought the musical heat — and lots of wild surprises.
On Aug. 11-13, Outside Lands returned to San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park for the 15th time. The city's premiere multi-day music and food festival attracted approximately 75,000 daily attendees, and promoter Another Planet says that about half of the 225,000 ticket holders live outside the Bay Area.
Though it takes place in the peak of summer, San Francisco in August is relatively cold and nicknamed "Fogust," which may have shocked any of the out of towners who showed up in shorts and barely-there tops.
The mild weather conditions meant that the true heat was left up to the performers to generate, and the more than 90 acts happily delivered. Below, we recount seven of the sets that were worth braving the summer cold to witness.
Shaq Takes Day One Championship
Moonlighting as DJ Diesel, NBA legend Shaquille O’Neal apologized for starting his incredibly surprising set a few minutes late.
"Sorry I’m late, I was just hanging with Steph Curry and Draymond Green," he said, name checking the Golden State Warriors’ star players. He laced his banter with basketball metaphors and later brought out Warriors guard Gary Payton II to play Queen’s "We Are The Champions" in the team’s honor.
After dropping jaws by firing up aggressively, atonal EDM beats, he invited the crush of fans to come up on stage and "party with Diesel" one at a time. His set veered from Guns N Roses to Imogen Heap and he has to be the first DJ to call for a "ladies only mosh pit" while playing Aqua’s "Barbie World."
When he threw a young blonde boy on his shoulders and they both pumped their fists in unison, it was everything — and that’s how a superhero DJs.
Janelle Monáe Celebrates The Fam
With a towering stack of Jamaican sound system-styled speakers, giant beach balls, a towel-waisted band and swimsuited dancers, Janelle Monáe brought the sexy "Black Sugar Beach" and "Lipstick Lover" vibes of her new album The Age of Pleasure to the Lands End main stage, which she last graced in 2018.
Monáe has since come out as nonbinary and greatly expanded her fanbase; at Outside Lands, she dedicated her performance to "my community, the LGBTQIA+ community," saying, "I love you so much. To be Black, to be queer, to be nonbinary, to evolve and to have family like you is a blessing."
Monáe’s natural charisma has only gotten sharper over time, and her dance moves are more infused with the quick steps of the Godfather of Soul James Brown and Prince. Her almost Rockettes-level line choreography with her dancers has leveled up as well.
This year’s Outside Lands also saw the debut of the LGBTQIA+-centric Dolores’ stage, which was powered all weekend by local party crews such as Hard French, Fake and Gay and Oasis. A highlight was Reparations, an all-Black drag show hosted by the incomparable Nicki Jizz, San Francisco’s serial Drag Queen of the Year (according to local publication 48 Hills) who wore a large penis hat that she claimed was true to her actual size. The most overtly queer-friendly edition of Outside Lands was something beautiful to continue and build on in the future.
Kendrick Lamar Brings The Friday Night Light
Last seen rapping to a small but rapturous crowd on a secondary stage at Outside Lands in 2015, Kendrick Lamar has grown immeasurably as a recording artist and live performer. Lamar commanded the Lands End stage, closing the festival’s first night with quietly assertive control and grace in a performance that felt like a rightful graduation. This veritable elder statesman slot has been previously held by major acts like Radiohead, Neil Young With Crazy Horse and Paul McCartney.
His 2022 album Mr. Morale & the Big Steppers featured prominently in the 21-song set, which included leftfield covers of Pusha T’s "Nosetalgia" and The Weeknd’s "Sidewalks." But Lamar knows that people still want to yell their lungs out to earlier cuts like "Swimming Pools (Drank)," "Bitch, Don’t Kill My Vibe," "m.A.A.d city," "HUMBLE." and "Alright" and he obliged.
Lana Del Rey Swings Back To Twin Peaks
Flower crowns were all the rage when Lana Del Rey made her Outside Lands debut in 2016 at Twin Peaks, the festival’s second largest stage. A new generation has since discovered the singer’s outsize character and vibe, and as the gates opened on Saturday, giddy groups of teenage girls rushed to park themselves at the edge of that very same stage to catch Del Rey’s big return to Golden Gate Park.
This time, Del Rey’s set included a projection that said "God Bless You San Francisco" and a giant swing woven with flowers that flung her into the air while she sang. Her set spanned her classics, like "Video Games" from 2012’s Born To Die, current hits, such as the title track from this year’s album Did You Know That There’s a Tunnel Under Ocean Blvd., and a loving cover of Tammy Wynette’s 1968 country hit "Stand By Your Man."
Though she’s revered as an almost otherworldly figure and was an angelic vision in white, Del Rey doesn’t act untouchable in 2023 — in fact, she literally came down and touched some of those fans who waited all day for her.
Foo Fighters Come Out Crooning
"We’ve gotta fit 28 years into two f—ing hours!" Dave Grohl explained early in the Foo Fighters' set. It was a towering goal that they tackled with consummate ease, reaching back to hits such as "Times Like These" and "The Pretender" and showing the continuum through to recent songs like "Rescue."
After playing a few choice riffs of "Enter Sandman," it would have been less of a surprise to see a member of two-time Outside Lands headliner (and Bay Area natives) Metallica join them on stage than who actually came out for a cameo. After flying in from Argentina, Michael Bublé initially pretended to be a regular audience member before going onstage to sing his hit "Haven’t Met You Yet."
The Foo-Bublé connection is fun and surprising: New drummer Josh Freese has also played for the Canadian crooner, and "Haven’t Met You Yet" is part of a medley that the Foo Fighters are doing on tour that is comprised of other bands Freese has supported (including Devo’s "Whip It" and Nine Inch Nails’ "March of the Pigs").
Of course, the late drummer Taylor Hawkins will always be a prominent part of the Foo Fighters and their shows, and they played "Aurora" in his memory. As the park’s Polo Field lit up in violet-colored lights, Grohl’s 17-year-old daughter Violet Grohl also joined to sing three songs with her father, which he said was his absolute favorite thing in the world to do.
"I’m sure I’m embarrassing her right now!" he said.
Gabriels Tributes Tina Turner
"We’re California boys, but this is our first time in San Francisco," shared Gabriels singer Jacob Lusk before turning the Sutro stage into the Church of Outside Lands, and instructing everyone to share some neighborly love.
The Los Angeles band has some meteoric fans: Elton John invited Lusk, whose early resume includes being a former "American Idol" contestant who was in a gospel group with the late Nate Dogg, to sing with him on stage at this year’s Glastonbury. Lusk’s incredible vocal range flexes from baritone to falsetto on a dime, and he frequently takes a step back from the microphone while singing, as if not to overwhelm it.
In a particularly touching moment, Gabriels performed Tina Turner’s "Private Dancer" while a montage of footage of Turner filled the screen.
Megan Thee Stallion Triumphs Over Tragedy
Fog flooded the park as a super snatched Megan Thee Stallion took to the stage in a hot Barbie pink outfit and long red hair, but she blazed through the haze with ground-sweeping twerking and saucy tracks like "Body," "Her," "WAP" and "Big Ole Freak." It was her first performance since Tory Lanez was sentenced to 10 years for shooting her, and she was feeling noticeably buoyant.
"F— all my haters!" she said in the middle of the set. "None of the s— you was doing or saying broke me."
She received nothing but love from the crowd, and she was delighted by a big pocket of "boys" that she saw. Meg truly loves her "Hotties," and even stopped in between songs to sign someone’s graduation cap. A recent grad herself, she is proud of her fans who follow suit.
"Real college girl s—!" she exclaimed.
7 Blazing Sets From Rolling Loud Miami 2023: Travis Scott, Sexyy Red, Rae Sremmurd & More

Photo: Peter Wafzig/Getty Images
list
Foo Fighters Essential Songs: 10 Tracks That Show The Band's Eternal Rock Spirit
On their recently released album, 'But Here We Are,' Dave Grohl and company offer a gripping confessional of both painful loss and blistering resilience. In honor of their 11th album, revisit 10 of the Foo Fighters’ most essential tracks.
Foo Fighters — one of contemporary rock’s most pivotal mainstays — boasts an almost mythical history. What began as Dave Grohl’s one-man band in 1994 after the devastating end of Nirvana has become a seminal machine with a catalog that spans three decades.
The group currently holds the record for the most GRAMMY wins in the Best Rock Album category, picking up awards in 2000 (There Is Nothing Left to Lose), 2003 (One By One), 2007 (Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace), 2012 (Wasting Light) and 2022 (Medicine at Midnight). At the 2023 GRAMMY Awards, Medicine at Midnight also took home awards for Best Rock Performance ("Making a Fire") and Best Rock Song ("Waiting on a War").
Their recently released 11th studio album, But Here We Are, is the facet’s first project following the death of drummer and vocalist Taylor Hawkins last year. Hawkins, who joined Foo Fighters in 1997 and would become a driving creative force in the group, was mourned by musicians and fans across the world. Tribute concerts in London and Los Angeles presented by the Hawkins family in conjunction with Foo gracefully paid homage to his legacy.
Grohl and company managed to push through their collective grief on But Here We Are. The project serves as a gripping confessional of both painful loss and blistering resilience. In honor of their latest endeavor, GRAMMY.com lists 10 of Foo Fighters’ most essential tracks.
"Big Me," Foo Fighters (1995)
Released one year after Kurt Cobain's death, Foo Fighters’ debut album brimmed with promise. "Losing Kurt was earth-shattering, and I was afraid of music after he died," he told Anderson Cooper during a 2014 episode of "60 Minutes."
Though Grohl insisted that the record was just an outlet for grief, it marked the beginning of his illustrious career. "Big Me," the final saccharine single from the project, proved that the drummer-turned-frontman had a knack for crafting catchy tunes that would become undeniable hits.
The campy nature of the track was the result of Grohl not putting much thought into the album, but that intrinsically simple approach — which trickled down to the song’s video which famously parodied Mentos commercials — was the start of something great.
"Everlong," The Colour and The Shape (1997)
One of Foo Fighters’ most exhilarating moments to date comes in the form of a love song. "Everlong," which was the second single from the band's sophomore effort, pulls listeners in with its gentle, melodic chords, keeping their attention with sweltering percussion and heart wrenching lyricism.
"Everlong" is about being so in tune with a romantic partner that the conclusion of that relationship is wholly devastating. "Come down and waste away with me," Grohl serenely sings. "Down with me/Slow, how you wanted it to be/I'm over my head/Out of her head, she sang." He performed it for the first time acoustic in 1998 on "The Howard Stern Show," which Grohl said "gave the song a whole new rebirth" during a performance at Oates Song Fest 7908.
"Breakout," There Is Nothing Left To Lose (1999)
"Breakout" appeared on both the band’s third album, There Is Nothing Left To Lose, and is filled with a frenzied, punk energy that channels Grohl’s grunge roots. While critics praised the album and noted the Foos' notable progression toward more melodic anthems, this quick, fast hit remains worthy of the hype it received over 20 years ago.
The track also appeared in the 2000 comedy film Me, Myself & Irene starring Jim Carrey, and several of its stars appear in its music video. There Is Nothing Left To Lose also spurred the radio hit "Learn To Fly," which won the GRAMMY Award for Best Short Form Music Video in 2000.
"Times Like These," One By One (2002)
The Foo Fighters' fourth studio album marked a turbulent period in the band’s history. Aside from personal issues, Grohl had just recorded drums for Queens of the Stone Age’s Songs for the Deaf, and joined the group for a subsequent tour.
While the fate of Foo remained unknown, a triumphant performance at Coachella in 2002 gave the members a new outlook on their future. "‘Times Like These’ was basically written about the band disappearing for those two or three months and me feeling like I wasn’t entirely myself," Grohl stated in the group’s 2011 documentary Back and Forth. "I just thought, ‘Okay, I’m not done being in the band. I don’t know if they are, but I’m not.’"
With its lyrical simplicity and crippling sincerity ("It’s times like these you learn to live again/It’s times like these you give and give again"), the song has come to embody love, togetherness and hope.
"Best Of You," In Your Honor (2005)
"I’ve got another confession to make/I’m your fool," Dave Grohl howls at the top of lungs on the riveting opening for "Best of You." His declaration is followed by the existential proposition: "Were you born to resist or be abused?"
In Your Honor’s lead single is ripe with emotion, in which the Foo frontman is buoyantly defiant and encourages those listening to his words to be the same. That sentiment was politically driven, as "Best of You" was penned after Grohl made several appearances on the 2004 Democratic presidential campaign for John Kerry.
"It’s not a political record, but what I saw inspired me," he told Rolling Stone in 2005. "It’s about breaking away from the things that confine you." "Best of You" is their only song in the U.S. to reach platinum status.
"The Pretender," Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace (2007)
One of the group’s most highest charting songs was "The Pretender," from 2007’s Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace. Grohl’s songwriting on the track is of macabre proportions, as introductory solemn chords give way to the lyrics: "Send in your skeletons/Sing as their bones go marching in again/They need you buried deep/The secrets that you keep are ever ready."
Heavier riffs and pulsating percussion make it quite the auditory experience. Perfectly paced crescendos on the "The Pretender" give it just the right amount of suspense, making it indelible to the Foo discography.
"White Limo", Wasting Light (2011)
In 2012, Wasting Light earned four GRAMMY Awards including Best Rock Album. "White Limo" snagged the accolade for Best Hard Rock/Metal Performance — and for good reason.
The second single from Foo Fighters’ seventh studio album is a ferocious number saturated with primal screams and whirlwind rhythms. "White Limo" was one of their most raucous songs to date and the group does their best Motorhead impression (Lemmy Kilmister’s appearance in the music video serves as the ultimate seal of approval). The group was intentional in maximizing their aggression on the heavy-metal track, making "White Limo" the sonic equivalent of a lightning bolt in their immense catalog.
"Make It Right," Concrete & Gold (2017)
2017’s Concrete and Gold wasn’t about redefining the wheel as much as it was perfecting it. The group’s ninth studio album is as rock 'n' roll as it gets.
There were a slew of memorable guest appearances including Paul McCartney on "Sunday Rain," Boyz II Men’s Shawn Stockman on "Concrete & Gold," and the Kills’ Alison Mosshart on "The Sky Is a Neighborhood" and "La Dee Da."
The album’s best track, "Make It Right," features an uncredited, sonically off-putting cameo from Justin Timberlake . Yet the collaboration’s venture into heavier territory pays off, with Grohl paying respect to Led Zeppelin. The rock legends' influence oozes all over "Make It Right" in the form of ragged taunts and splintering riffs. Timberlake slinks into the background with additional vocals, making sure to not alter Foo’s formula in any way.
"Waiting on a War," Medicine at Midnight (2021)
Foo Fighters’ 10th album, Medicine at Midnight, was a refreshing return to form for the rockers.
Sparked by a conversation by Grohl’s daughter, "Waiting on a War" embodied the group’s pensiveness about America’s ominous future. Over four minutes, Grohl states that he’s "waiting for the sky to fall," though his melancholy thoughts ultimately transform from wistful crooning over acoustic guitar chords to a rumbling, full-throated ferocious outro. Foo’s bold approach snagged them a GRAMMY Award in 2022 for Best Rock Song.
"Rescued," But Here We Are (2023)
The power in "Rescued," the emotionally-charged first single from But Here We Are, relies not only on the lyrics to spell out the feeling of despondency, but on Grohl’s expression of them.
"We’re all free to some degree/To dance under the lights," he sings. "I’m just waiting to be rescued/Bring me back to life." His voice languishes between fatigue and vigor as swirling guitars and ethereal buildups provide catharsis for both the band and the listener. The vulnerability of "Rescued" channels the intriguing self-awareness heard on albums like The Colour and The Shape and In Your Honor. But this song represents a brand new chapter for Foo and it’s one that confronts their pain head on.

Photo: Scarlet Page
feature
Foo Fighters’ Road To ‘But Here We Are’: How The Rock Survivors Leaned Into Their Grief
Foo Fighters are returning to the fray after the death of drummer Taylor Hawkins with a new album, 'But Here We Are.' Ahead of its release, take a look at how Dave Grohl and co. rose to the status of America's biggest rock band.
"10 songs that run the emotional gamut from rage and sorrow to serenity and acceptance, and myriad points in between." Without knowledge of their recent history, Foo Fighters' summary of their forthcoming record sounds like the usual pre-release spiel. Yet, as with everything Dave Grohl has touched over the past 35 years, this statement is grounded firmly in authenticity.
But Here We Are is the Foos' 11th studio effort and first record since the untimely passing of Taylor Hawkins, just hours before they were due on stage at Colombia's Estéreo Picnic Festival in March 2022. The drummer had been the backbone of the constantly changing group for quarter of a century, and so his death at the age of just 50 inevitably threw their future into question. Following hugely affecting tribute concerts on both sides of the Atlantic, Grohl et al concluded, much to fans’ relief, that the show must go on.
Expectedly, the devastation of losing a bandmate permeates their first studio effort since; it takes just 12 seconds to position But Here We Are as something of a musical eulogy. "It came in a flash/It came out of nowhere/It happened so fast/And then it was over," an anguished Grohl sings on opener "Rescued," one of many attempts to make sense of the sudden nature of his bandmate's death. But while the album's words are often steeped in melancholy, its sound is lean and loud.
First taster"Rescued" harks back to the '00s triple whammy of lead singles ("All My Life," "Best of You," "The Pretender") by combining stadium-sized hooks with speaker-blowing guitar riffs and dynamic rhythms. Perhaps not in the right headspace to hire a permanent replacement, Grohl returned to his former day job by taking to the drum kit for all ten tracks. And the majority of this third consecutive collaboration with Greg Kurstin, the super producer best-known for his work with pop powerhouses Adele and Sia, shares a similar full-blooded energy.
Of course, the Foos were born out of a similar tragedy. Grohl only made that rare leap from drummer to frontman in the wake of Nirvana bandmate Kurt Cobain's 1994 suicide. The "nicest guy in rock" had initially considered joining Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers before heading into the studio to test out his singer/songwriter skills. Knocked out in just five days, the 15 tracks that emerged were distributed on cassette to friends, with the overwhelmingly positive feedback inspiring Grohl to pursue the Foo Fighters ("the stupidest f—ing band name in the world," he'd later concede) concept further.
Grohl quickly assembled a line-up that included drummer William Goldsmith and bassist Nate Mendel of the defunct Sunny Day Real Estate and Nirvana's brief touring second guitarist Pat Smear to help perform the self-titled debut he issued on his own Roswell Records label. Fans hoping for insights into Grohl’s state of mind may have been left disappointed: Feeling pressured to address Cobain's demise, he opted for a stream-of-consciousness lyrical approach that resulted in gibberish.
First taster "Rescued" harks back to the '00s triple whammy of lead singles ("All My Life," "Best of You," "The Pretender") by combining stadium-sized hooks with speaker-blowing guitar riffs and dynamic rhythms. Perhaps not in the right headspace to hire a permanent replacement, Grohl returned to his former day job by taking to the drum kit for all ten tracks. And the majority of this third consecutive collaboration with Greg Kurstin, the super producer best-known for his work with pop powerhouses Adele and Sia, shares a similar full-blooded energy.
Of course, the Foos were born out of a similar tragedy. Grohl only made that rare leap from drummer to frontman in the wake of Nirvana bandmate Kurt Cobain's 1994 suicide. The "nicest guy in rock" had initially considered joining Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers before heading into the studio to test out his singer/songwriter skills. Knocked out in just five days, the 15 tracks that emerged were distributed on cassette to friends, with the overwhelmingly positive feedback inspiring Grohl to pursue the Foo Fighters ("the stupidest f—ing band name in the world," he'd later concede) concept further.
Grohl quickly assembled a line-up that included drummer William Goldsmith and bassist Nate Mendel of the defunct Sunny Day Real Estate and Nirvana's brief touring second guitarist Pat Smear to help perform the self-titled debut he issued on his own Roswell Records label. Fans hoping for insights into Grohl’s state of mind may have been left disappointed: Feeling pressured to address Cobain's demise, he opted for a stream-of-consciousness lyrical approach that resulted in gibberish.
However, Foo Fighters' sound wasn't too much of a departure from the quiet/loud grunge-rock that had catapulted Nirvana to blockbuster success. And despite a deliberate lack of promotion, melodic singles such as "This Is A Call" and "Big Me" — the latter penned in honor of Grohl's then-wife Jennifer Youngblood — steered the record to nearly 1.5 million domestic sales and the first of many GRAMMY nominations. Interestingly, it lost Best Alternative Music Album to Nirvana's MTV Unplugged in New York.
1997 follow-up The Colour and the Shape also had ties to Grohl's previous day job. "February Stars" derived from a Nirvana recording session with bassist Krist Novoselic in early 1994, while producer Gil Norton had also worked with the Pixies — Cobain's biggest inspiration. And just like Nevermind, it's a sophomore that remains its band's commercial peak: despite charting no higher than No. 10 on the Billboard 200, it's still the Foos' biggest seller.
Although the group now sounded even bigger than before, their lyrics this time round were of a far more intimate nature. Propulsive lead single "Monkey Wrench" is one of several numbers inspired by the breakdown of Grohl's marriage, a period the rocker has described as the winter of his discontent, while "Everlong" (David Letterman's all-time favorite song) found him lauding new love, Veruca Salt’s Louise Post. There was even talk of placing a therapist's couch on the album artwork to reflect the more confessional tone.
But The Colour and the Shape also kickstarted a personnel merry-go-round: Goldsmith left to be replaced by Alanis Morissette drummer Hawkins, while Smear followed suit soon after due to exhaustion. Within a year, his successor Franz Stahl, formerly of Grohl's early hardcore punk outfit Scream, had been given his marching orders over the age-old reason of creative differences.
By the time There Is Nothing Left to Lose hit the shelves in 1999, the Foos had been reduced to a three-piece. Nevertheless, what they'd lost in members they appeared to gain in melodies. Accompanied by an MTV-dominating video in which Grohl assumed multiple identities, "Learn to Fly" became the band’s first Hot 100 hit. And the swoonsome college rock of "Next Year" proved the band could be compelling without turning things up to eleven. It was little surprise when they scooped their first-ever GRAMMY for Best Rock Album.
Whereas There Is... was created in idyllic circumstances ("It was one of the most relaxing times of my whole life," Grohl later enthused. "All we did was eat chili, drink beer and whiskey and record whenever we felt like it"), the recording of 2002's One by One was fraught with tension. Firstly, Hawkins had delayed proceedings when a heroin overdose left him in a coma for two weeks. Then Mendel and Grohl spent most of their studio time warring with each other, with new guitarist Chris Shiflett often left twiddling his thumbs as a result. The situation eventually got so bad their headline slot at Coachella was regarded as make-or-break.
Luckily, the band enjoyed playing together again on stage so much they decided to keep the Foos train running. And after re-recording much of the material Hawkins dismissed as "million-dollar demos" in Grohl's basement, One by One eventually saw the light of day. Despite such a difficult inception, the album spawned two of the group's most enduring songs: the turbo-charged ode to oral sex that is "All My Life" and the contrastingly sweet "Times Like These," a self-help anthem which has since been championed by everyone from Glen Campbell to George W. Bush (and taken to the UK No. 1 spot by a Grohl-led charity supergroup).
While Grohl later became disillusioned with One by One ("four of the songs were good, and the other seven I've never played again in my life"), he's remained positive about 2005 follow-up In Your Honor, a double album which allowed the Foos to showcase both their full-throttle and sensitive sides. Audiences appeared just as enthused about this separation of electrified and stripped-back material: it posted the highest first-week sales of the group's career. GRAMMY voters leaned into all the magnum opus talk, showering the LP with five nominations. However, the band still went home empty-handed on Music's Biggest Night.
A disappointing awards haul is far from the only notable thing about In Your Honor, though. Based on his experiences living with Cobain and Novoselic, "Friend of a Friend" originates from 1990, making it Grohl's first acoustic composition. "Cold Day in the Sun" gives Hawkins a debut on lead vocals, while Norah Jones collaboration "Virginia Moon," an unlikely detour into bossa nova, is the band's first duet.
2007’s Echoes, Silence, Grace and Patience also boasted a Foo Fighters milestone: "Ballad of the Beaconsfield Miners" was their first ever instrumental piece. But elsewhere, the band went back to basics, reuniting with Norton to produce what some considered to be a belated sequel to The Colour and the Shape. Once again, multiple GRAMMY nods followed, although on this occasion, the Foos got to add to their trophy cabinet, winning Best Rock Album and Best Hard Rock Performance for anthemic lead single "The Pretender."
A 2009 Greatest Hits compilation appeared to close the door of another Foo Fighters' era. Yet 2011's Wasting Light suggested the group still had one eye on the past. Not only did they invite Smear back into the recording fold, they also hired Butch Vig — the man behind Nevermind — as producer, asked Novoselic to guest and made the whole thing analog-style in Grohl's Encino garage ("Why go into the most expensive studio with the biggest producer and use the best state-of-the-art equipment?" he posited. "Where's the rock 'n' roll in that?")
The nostalgic approach paid off when Wasting Light became the Foos' first U.S. chart-topper and added three GRAMMY Awards to their collection. However, few fans would agree it achieved Grohl's goal to create the band's definitive album, its 11 tracks following the arena rock handbook just a little too closely to stand out.
Playing it safe is not an accusation you could level at 2014's Sonic Highways, an albumteased by Grohl as one made "in a way that no-one's ever done before." And he wasn't exaggerating. Accompanied by a same-named HBO documentary in which the rocker interviewed local musicians, engineers and producers, the highly ambitious project attempted to recapture the musical spirit of eight different American cities.
The Foos also roped in several hometown heroes on record, with country star Zac Brown representing Nashville, Cheap Trick frontman Rick Nielsen flying the flag for Chicago and, most unexpectedly of all, the Preservation Hall Jazz Band paying tribute to New Orleans. The Vig-produced affair was still very much a Foo Fighters album, albeit one steeped in classic rather than alternative rock.
The unpredictable collaborations continued on 2017's Concrete and Gold, a deliberately weird record featuring Boyz II Men's Shawn Stockman, saxophonist Dave Koz and Justin Timberlake, not to mention Paul McCartney on drums. The strangest aspect of the album for Grohl, however, was the location of its recording: "I thought, 'What's the strangest thing for this band to do at this point?' And then I realized it was just to go into a studio and make a f—ing album like a normal band," he told Rolling Stone.
The first LP since keyboardist Rami Jafeee became a permanent member took a little longer to make than expected: Grohl was forced out of action for six months after breaking his leg during an on-stage fall in Sweden. The timeout, which occurred during Donald Trump's rise to power, allowed the frontman to take stock of America's future, resulting in the Foos' most politically charged effort as well as their poppiest.
Foo Fighters doubled down on the big hooks for 2021's Medicine at Midnight, resulting in their first ever consecutive No.1. Grohl even compared it to Let's Dance, the David Bowie record which briefly reinvented the musical chameleon as the ultimate party-starter. GRAMMY voters obviously approved, awarding the band Best Rock Album, Best Rock Song for "Waiting on a War" and Best Rock Performance for "Making a Fire." Of course, just over a year later the feel-good vibes dissipated in the most heartbreaking way imaginable.
Whereas Grohl completely avoided the subject of Cobain's passing on Foo Fighters’ debut LP, almost every song on their 11th album alludes to Hawkins'.
Under You" finds Grohl looking at "pictures of us sharing cigarettes and songs," going through the various stages of grief via a punchy piece of power pop. And on the cathartic title track, the frontman unleashes the kind of fierce, throat-busting howls more suited to his extracurricular forays into death metal.
And then there's the behemoth named "The Teacher." Surpassing "Come Back" as the Foos' longest song, the 10-minute epic is also one of their most powerful, encompassing themes of existential despair and extolling various life lessons ("Try to make good with the air that's left/Counting every minute, living breath by breath") while segueing from riotous post-grunge to bittersweet folk-rock and back again.
But Here We Are does have other quieter moments of introspection. Violet Maye Grohl — teenage daughter of the Foos’ leader — lends her cooing tones and a reassuring presence ("I'll take care of everything from now on") to the gorgeously ethereal melodies and dreamy crystalline guitars of "Show Me How." And there's unlikely to be a dry eye in the house as a hushed Grohl Sr. bids a final farewell on the closing stripped-back bars of finale Rest, ("Waking up, I had another dream of us/In the warm Virginia sun/There I will meet you").
The recent appointment of Josh Freese, the journeyman drummer who appears to have played with every notable rock band of the past 30 years, appears to confirm this won't be the last we hear from Foo Fighters. Indeed, Grohl and company have described But Here We Are as "the first chapter of the band's new life." This heartfelt yet utterly emphatic tribute suggests it will be just as compelling as those gone by.